Sell Us Your Cards

Buylist Lookup

Find out how much we'll pay for your cards!

All prices listed are Cash values for cards in Near Mint condition. We pay less for cards that our buyers grade as Slightly Played or Heavily Played.

Get 25% more on your non-Bulk cards when you take your payment in Jupiter Games Store Credit!

You can also Browse our Full Buylist on a single page (no images).

We're not buying Magic Singles right now due to the COVID-19 pandemic, but we have a few ideas on how we might be able start buying again safely in the near future!

Sell your Magic Singles to Jupiter Games

Selling your Magic Cards to Jupiter Games is easy!

Bring your prepared cards to our Buy Station, located at our back counter, and firmly press the button on the counter for service. (You should hear a soft chime). One of our Buyers will be out to help you momentarily.

Our Buyer will review your cards and tell you how much we will purchase them for. The buy price quoted for each card will be based on the card's base buy price and condition.

Once the buy offer is finalized, you will have the option of being paid in cash, by check, or in store credit. Payouts over $300 must be taken as a check or in store credit.

You'll get 25% more on your non-bulk cards when you take your payment as Store Credit!

To Sell Your Magic Cards by Mail, Click Here.

Preparing Your Cards for Sale

A little bit of preparation will help us buy your cards more quickly!

Remove the cards you wish to sell from your binder.

Remove any sleeves from your cards.

You may keep your more valuable cards sleeved.

Optional: Sort your buylist cards by name.

Please use the tables in our Event Center if you need to prepare your cards in-store.

Separate your cards into these categories:

  • Cards that are on our Buylist
  • Bulk foil rares & mythics
  • Bulk non-foil mythics
  • Bulk non-foil rares [w/ gold symbol]
  • Bulk foil commons & uncommons
  • Bulk foil basic lands
  • Bulk promo cards (foil & non-foil
  • Bulk non-foil commons & uncommons
  • Bulk non-foil basic lands
  • *Tokens and inserts are not bulk*

Please contact us in advance to verify in-store buyer availability when trading collections,
high-value cards, or if you're traveling a fair distance to sell cards.

Buying Hours

Monday - Friday CLOSED
Saturday CLOSED

Bulk Magic Singles

We buy bulk cards at the following rates:


Bulk Mythics ($0.20)

Bulk Rares (with gold set symbol) ($0.08)

Bulk Commons & Uncommons ($3/1000)


Bulk Foil Rares and Mythics ($0.20)

Bulk Foil Commons & Uncommons ($0.04)


Bulk Promos ($0.04)

Tokens & Inserts are not Bulk.

Last Updated: 2/19/18

Grading Guidelines - Card Conditions

Near Mint:

A card in Near Mint condition will show little to no wear. It may have a light scratch, small nick, or barely noticeable border wear. A foil card will have little to no clouding and retain most or all of its original gloss.

Slightly Played:

These cards are purchased at 80% of the Near Mint price. A card in Slightly Played condition will show visible, minor wear. It may have mild border or corner wear, minor bending, light scratching, small nicks, light scuffing, or very minor border creasing. A foil card may also have moderate clouding and have lost some of its original gloss.

Moderately and Heavily Played:

These cards are purchased at 50-60% of the Near Mint price. A card in Moderately Played condition will show easily visible, but not extreme wear. It may have extensive border or corner wear, major bending, major scratching, major nicks, major scuffing, major creasing along the top border from shuffling, moderate whitening, slight inking along the borders, slight tearing along the borders, minor water damage, minor dirt buildup, or slight discoloration. A foil card may also have major clouding and have lost most of its original gloss. A card in Heavily Played condition will show all of the above to a greater extent.

We are not presently buying cards signed by the artist, Richard Garfield, or bearing a Pro Tour Stamp. If these cards would otherwise be graded as Near Mint, they will instead be graded as Moderately Played.


We do not accept Damaged cards.

A card in Damaged condition will show easily visible, extreme wear. It may have major whitening, heavy inking, major creasing or tearing, extensive water damage, writing on the front or back, missing pieces, extensive dirt buildup, or extreme discoloration. A foil card that is Damaged may also have lost all of its original gloss.

Cards that exhibit a discernible odor are Damaged.

Please note that these percentages will be lower on older, more collectible sets such as Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, etc.

If you have any questions about our grading policies, please email our lead buyer.

Buy online and have your cards shipped to your door, or use our convenient contactless pickup service and pick up your cards in as little as an hour!

How do I place an order for pickup?
  1. 1.) Place your Magic Singles order online through this website.
    You will have the option to pay for your order with a credit/debit card or with an existing PayPal account.

  2. 2.) If you would like to add any sealed Magic products, card accessories (sleeves/deckboxes) or other games, place a separate order through our new online store at
    You will have the option of paying via credit/debit card or Apple/Google pay (depending on your device).

  3. 3.) Once you have placed and paid for your order(s), book an appointment for pickup using our online scheduling tool at

How does Contactless Pickup work?

  • * You may pick up your items ONLY during your scheduled appointment. If you cannot make your appointment you may reschedule your appointment online. DO NOT come to the store outside of the time slot that you booked when making your appointment online.

  • * ALL items must be purchased in advance. You may not purchase additional items or "add on" to your order at the door.

  • * You MUST wear a mask or other face covering at all times during your pickup appointment. It MUST cover both your mouth and your nose.

  • * When it's time for your scheduled appointment, please approach our back door. One of our staff will meet you there to facilitate your contactless pickup. If there's no one at the door please knock on the glass and someone will be right with you.

When will Jupiter Games reopen for in-store shopping?
  • We do not yet have a solid timeline for when we will be reopening our retail store to in-person shopping.