Selling Your Cards by Mail

Step 1: Review Our Buy Prices

Check our buylist to find our buying prices for your cards.

Step 2: Send Us a Sell Request

Send an email to with the list of cards you wish to sell, along with their conditions, formatted per the example posted under "How to Format Your Sell Request".

*Please note that we have a $10.00 minimum on all card buys*

Step 3: We'll Review Your Sell Request

We'll review your Sell Request, and we'll let you know within 2 business days if your Sell Request has been approved.

Jupiter Games reserves the right to refuse to buy any cards for any reason.

Step 4: Ship Us Your Cards

If approved, print out a copy of the email and your card list and send them, along with your cards, to our buying address:

Jupiter Games
Attn: Buyer
P.O. Box 888
Johnson City, NY 13790

If you have any additional questions about the process of shipping your cards to us, please email

Step 5: We'll Review Your Cards

Once your cards are received, they will be checked to ensure all cards listed are present and in the condition that was listed in your email. If there are any discrepancies in cards or grading, you will be emailed an adjusted total buy price before the buy is processed.

If your cards need to be returned for any reason, you will be responsible for the shipping cost. This can be paid via PayPal.

Step 6: You Get Paid

You can choose to receive payments via PayPal or check; pleased be advised that PayPal payments will arrive more quickly than checks. We are not offering trade at this time. Payments are usually sent within a 7 business days of confirmed receipt of your cards.

Please note that if you select payment via PayPal, some fees may apply. A list of Paypal fees can be found here:

How to Format Your Sell Request

Send an email to

Be sure to include your Name, Phone Number, Mailing Address and the Email Address associated with your PayPal account (if you choose to be paid via PayPal).

Please format your card list as follows:

Card Name - Edition (Condition) Card Price (Quantity) Total
ie. Snapcaster Mage - Innistrad (NM) $30 (2) $60
Bulk Rares -$0.08 (128) $10.24
Grand Total: $70.24

Alternately, you can attach an Excel Spreadsheet (.xls file) to your message, formatted as follows:

Card Name | Edition | Condition | Buy Price | Quantity | Total Buy Value

How to Ship Your Cards

Make sure that the order of the cards you include match the order you listed in your original email. Both your confirmation email and your sell list email should be printed out and included with your cards. Failure to follow either of these steps will delay processing time and payment.

Package cards securely, making sure they are not able to move around. Row boxes and plastic card cases made specifically for trading cards are good choices for packaging, using packing material around the outside if necessary. You may ship via USPS, UPS, or FedEx, though we suggest using a method that allows you to track your package. Please ship your order within 2 days of receiving your confirmation email. If your order is not postmarked within two business days of your confirmation e-mail, we cannot guarantee the prices at time of submission.

Jupiter Games is not responsible for items lost or damaged during shipping.

International Shipments

Shipments from countries outside the U.S. will take additional time to process, and customs or import fees are your responsibility. We will email you with any fees associated with your package and they will be deducted from your final payment.

Foreign Language Cards

Jupiter Games is not buying cards printed in languages other than English at this time. Any non-English cards sent to us will be returned at your cost.

Counterfeit Cards

Jupiter Games does not buy non-genuine Magic cards. This includes, but is not limited to: counterfeit cards, playtest cards, and custom tokens. If any of the cards we receive are counterfeit, the card(s) will be destroyed and you will be notified.